Mother’s Day is just around the corner, which means it’s the time of year for flower bouquets, tea parties, and spa dates. But for Asian and Hapa families, cultural expectations make this celebration… well, a little more complicated.
Earlier this week on Twitter, Calvin Ho posed the question:
— Calvin Ho (@calvinhyj) May 9, 2012
As Calvin expands on his blog, The Plaid Bag Connection, many of the conventional Mother’s Day treats seem a little ludicrous for your typical Asian immigrant mom.
Even the simple, at-home things these blogs suggest aren’t going to work. For example, I’ve always wondered how my mother would react to the very Western idea of breakfast in bed. Breakfast in bed would completely violate the sanctity and cleanliness of the Chinese sleeping space.
My suggestion? Really, all any self-respecting Chinese (or Taiwanese, Korean, Vietnamese, etc.) matron could really want is your undying gratitude. That, and maybe a nice spouse and 2.5 kids and a career in the medical field.
Luckily, other tweeters had some more *ahem* attainable suggestions, such as gourmet coffee or a UV blocking visor, which Calvin rounds up here.
In all seriousness, as I’ve had children of my own (and butted heads mightily with my own mother in raising them) and watched them grow, I think I have a better idea of the heart of a mother. Not just a mommy of little kids, but a mother of individuals who have their own minds and opinions that might not be anything like what you hoped they would be.
What every Asian mother wants, I think, is to be understood and appreciated. Their advice may not be endorsed by Doctors Spock, Brazelton or Sears, but there are some nuggets of wisdom mixed in with their sometimes comical advice, of which Audrey Magazine has a great series.
After buying into the new-mommy hype of Mother’s Day (it’s almost as important as the day you gave birth! or your wedding!), I’ve decided I prefer a low-key celebration: a drive through the country and a picnic in a scenic location, or just brunch — okay, and dinner — out with the family. Oh yeah, and if my boys could actually be dressed in clean, matching clothes without any logos, that would be wonderful, too. Maybe we could even take our picture together.
If you are looking for ideas for your Tiger Mother, here’s what I suggest:
Skip the Hallmark store and spend some time with your mother. Drive her to the Chinatown or Asian mall that’s too far for her to get to on surface streets. Ask her how she’s doing and listen to what she has to say, and don’t argue with her non-PC remarks. Actually wear the crazy shirt she brought from her last trip to Taiwan, or go with her to the Coach outlet and earnestly help her decide whether the bag with the big-C’s or little C’s is better.
I’m pretty sure that would make any Asian mother happy.
(7) Readers Comments
January 28, 2013
March 05, 2013
April 05, 2012
May 03, 2012
April 03, 2012
December 12, 2013
December 01, 2013
Yup! When I went back to grab my old post from OS, I got all misty-eye
I love this! And it makes me feel bad that I didn't participate in Le
hi, i'm interested in the tickets!
Point well taken, Jean. Caring for family members, whether very young
My sisters' in-laws actually have been better caretakers for their gra